Wednesday, March 2, 2022

Doctor Sleep and The Shining, two book reviews by Eleanore Vance



Doctor Sleep:


Thiry-six years in the making, King's novel takes us on a trip to see Danny Torrence All Grown Up. The years have not been kind. Danny has become an alcoholic, mostly, I think to dim his shine. 


We see him hit rock bottom and then leave town. This moment haunts him throughout the novel.  But only about a third of the book belongs to Danny. He shares this story with Rose the Hat and her True Knot, as well as Abra Stone, a young girl with blinding shine. 


This book is tight and sleek. Compared to his earlier, looser epics, it is downright space-aged! I really appreciated that about this story. Not exactly what anyone would call action-packed, but good pacing keeps us moving and we never feel the story lag. I even feel that a lot of King's usual sexist remarks are cut back in this book. 


I do have issues, though. I would have liked to see Danny angry with Jack. Or Wendy angry with Jack. I really felt that to leave out the hurt and rage that would accompany the healing process from the events of the Overlook is really tone-deaf. Also, Danny's Deep Dark Secret reveal at the end is a lie. 

Otherwise, a solid adventure. Highly reccomend. 


⭐⭐⭐⭐4/5



The Shining:


Many of us first met the Torrence family in Kubrick's iconic film, I know I did. That film splits the book's fanbase, some with Steve hating it, others not. The novel seems to be a creature of similar genus, but not the same species. I personally understand many of Kubrick's directorial decisions, but we're not here to talk about the film. 


Jack Torrence is an alcoholic.  He's neither  a drowsy drunk, nor a jovial drunk. And he is definitely not an "I love you, man" drunk. He is what I would term a volatile drunk. Not dangerous if alone, but can combust with great violence when mixed with other elements. Results unpredictable. Some of these results include breaking the arm if his young (three-to-five years old) son for spilling some school papers, and a possible hit and run of a cyclist while driving drunk. I wish I could tell you that all of this scared Jack straight into the arms of AA. Instead, an incident involving a student at the fancy prep school where Jack teaches causes him to lose said employment and sends the Torrence family away from New England in search of a fresh start. 

Wendy is brilliant, savvy and well-educated. She's a good mom. But there is something about her... something that says she's been abused and she just can't admit it to herself, let alone to anyone else. 


And then there is Little Danny of the broken arm. Danny has an "imaginary friend" called Tony. And there's something very special about Danny. He shines. 


The Overlook Hotel should have been the Torrence Family's salvation, (maybe in a sick way it was) instead that winter is their own personal version of Hell. King says he has done his best to write Jack as a guy who only does bad stuff when he drinks. I just can't see him that way. Jack's story isn't the one I sympathize with, its Wendy and Danny. 


I dare y'all to read this book the next rime it looks like snow. Pace yourself, though. This is a 1977 King classic, and he greatly distrusted editors at this time. That said, he has a tendency to meander 


⭐⭐⭐3/5





 





No comments:

Post a Comment